Investigation Policy & Transparency

The Statutory Void: Federal Wildfire Use, Agency Discretion, and the Limits of Compensation for Affected Landowners

No organic statute authorizes managing wildfire for resource benefit — and when that practice destroys private property, the discretionary function exception closes the courthouse door. A legal history from the Organic Act of 1897 to the Black Fire.

By ,

About the author

Frank Carroll

Frank Carroll

My name is Frank Carroll. I'm a wildfire consultant and a veteran of the Forest Service. For the last decade or so I've been deeply engaged in wildfire policy, and in looking at the overarching picture of wildfire management, forest management, and active management in the United States on both public and private lands.

All work by Frank Carroll

Media inquiries about this report

Contact us about any report or story on this site.

All research
NWA Newsletter

Stay informed

Subscribe to the National Wildfire Alliance newsletter and receive the latest on wildfire policy, forest management and community protection.

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

Download PDF Cite this